The Wonder That a Feather Is
By John Palka — Posted June 2, 2019
Perhaps no other season feels as welcome to us as does spring. The winter months are beautiful, but they are a time of rest and quietude, a time when Nature slows down. We associate winter with short days, low temperatures, and snow or rain, and we relish the coziness of home. But as the days start to lengthen and the Sun starts to feel warm on the skin, we feel ourselves drawn outside. The snow disappears. Subtle, fresh colors appear on the plants. And the birds, many of them arriving from faraway lands, announce their presence with song, the males establishing territories and courting females. Spring is here!
Many of the birds are clad in brilliant plumage. The color patterns in the plumage are highly specific and are used by the birds as social signals or for camouflage. To a biologist, the feathers themselves raise a host of questions: How are the colors produced? How are the striking patterns produced? Indeed, how are individual feathers produced? How did feathers originate during evolution? What physiological functions do feathers serve? And on and on.
We won’t be able to tackle all these questions in a single post, so let’s start with the one to which the answers are easiest to offer, the source of the colors that so draw our eyes. As we’ll see, there is abundant complexity even here!
BLACK AND WHITE
A good starting point is thinking about those proverbial opposites, black and white. Here are three central ideas.
- We can only see light that reaches our eyes; we cannot see light traveling in directions that miss our eyes. When, for example, we see the feathers of a bird while the Sun is behind us (so that the rays of sunlight are traveling away from us), we are seeing only the light in which the direction of travel has been reversed back to our eyes by something in the feathers.
- As we have seen in earlier posts, sunlight contains many colors, that is, many wavelengths. When these varying wavelengths are spread out, we see a range of colors side by side, for example in a rainbow or when a shaft of light passes through the beveled edge of a window pane. A white object looks white because it reflects all these wavelengths. This statement will be crucial later when we talk about specific colors rather than white or black.
- A black material looks black because it reflects no visible light in our direction.
How do these rather abstract ideas relate to real birds and their feathers? Here is one example.
All the the feathers of the trumpeter swan on the left are white (the orange tint on the head and neck is discoloration picked up when the swan feeds under the lake water). Why such pure white? Here are some reasons:
- Some of the light striking the swan has been redirected in our direction. That’s why we see the swan in the first place.
- The internal structure of white feathers is such that it causes what scientists sometimes call wavelength-independent diffuse scattering, meaning that light is redirected in a way that does not depend on its wavelength. This is why the feathers look white to us—all the wavelengths contained in sunlight have been redirected equally well.
- Finally, the light is redirected by scattering. Sunlight arrives at each feather basically from one direction, from wherever the Sun happens to be. It is redirected equally in all directions. The effect of this is that the swan’s feathers look equally white and equally bright no matter from which direction we look at them.
The swan’s feathers are white, but its beak and feet are black. In contrast to the swan, the goose has some feathers that are jet black, some that are brilliant white, and many that are brownish. Its beak is black, just like the swan’s. What creates this pattern?
Biological structures, whether they are feathers or bills or skin or anything else, usually look black because they contain the pigment melanin which absorbs all wavelengths of light. Light that has been absorbed cannot be reflected, scattered, or redirected in any way and thus cannot be seen. A melanin-containing object is dark to the extent that its melanin absorbs the light being shone on it. More melanin means more absorption, so melanin-containing structures range from pale grey to jet black.
What about the brownish feathers of the goose? They, too, contain melanin, but they are slightly colored. That’s because melanin comes in several chemical forms. One is truly black. Another is brownish, meaning that it absorbs wavelengths somewhat unequally. And yet another is actually reddish because it absorbs light at the blue end of the visible spectrum slightly better than it does light at the red end, so that the remaining, unabsorbed light has a warm tint. The exact color of a biological structure containing melanin and no other pigments is determined by the balance among the handful of varieties of melanin.
We can see this principle operating in another bird, the red-breasted nuthatch.
This nuthatch displays much the same colors as did the swans and geese, though arranged in a different pattern. Once again there is brilliant white, plus black and grey. Instead of the brownish color of Canada geese there is yellow-orange on the breast. All these colors except for white result from the absorption characteristics of the several melanins. In the case of white, of course, there is no melanin, no absorption due to a specific pigment, just “wavelength-independent scattering” yielding white.
EXPANDING THE COLOR PALETTE
Melanins are the most widely distributed pigments in the animal world, and birds use them to generate an enormous range of colors and color patterns. Melanins are not, however, the only pigments used by birds. Just look at this goldfinch!
Once again we see black and white in a bird’s plumage. However, what most catches our eye is the brilliant yellow. Where does this come from?
Bird colors generated by pigments are produced primarily by two classes of molecules, melanins and carotenoids, though others also exist.
- Melanins we have already encountered. In bird feathers they come in two principal classes, and in addition to black and grey they yield a range of muted colors, mostly with a warmish cast. Melanins are produced by biosynthetic pathways in an organism’s own cells, under instruction from its genes.
- Carotenoids are red and yellow pigments of which many variants are known. Virtually no animals are able to synthesize their own carotenoids, so they must obtain these from their diets. In birds, some carotenoids are used by the bird’s cells in the chemical form in which they were ingested; others are biochemically modified so that they produce a different color than they would have in their original dietary form.
Our goldfinch takes advantage of both melanins and carotenoids—its black feathers are rich in melanins while its yellow feathers are packed with carotenoids. The white feathers, of course, are devoid of any specific pigments.
Now here is an aspect of the story that has nothing to do with pigments. The yellow is so intense and so brilliant in part because microscopic structures in the interior of the feathers reflect light outward. This allows the carotenoid pigments to do what pigments always do, absorb some wavelengths and transmit others, but with this added twist: The wavelength-dependent absorption takes place while light is on its way from the feathers to the eyes of the observer—that’s us and, of course, it’s also other goldfinches who might be potential mates or rivals. This is what allows the now-yellow light to be seen. When this reflection is experimentally eliminated, the yellow fades until it is hardly detectable.
Like goldfinches, cardinals also produce melanin and utilize dietary carotenoids to lend color to their brilliant plumage. A breeding male has no white feathers.
Though they both rely heavily on carotenoids, goldfinches and cardinals have different colors. This is partly because they select different diets and partly because of their internal biochemistry. For example, when the normal diet of goldfinches is experimentally supplemented with red carotenoids, their feathers turn orange. On the other hand, when cardinals are completely deprived of red carotenoids, they still grow pale red feathers. Conclusion? Goldfinches can use a variety of carotenoids in their diet, and the purity of their yellow depends at least partly on how selective they are in what they eat. Cardinals, too, depend on dietary carotenoids to produce their intensely red plumage. When only yellow carotenoids are available in their diet, however, they can biochemically convert these into red carotenoids at least to a limited extent.
THERE IS ANOTHER WAY
Thus far we have seen that pigments generate colors by absorbing some wavelengths of light more than others. In this way they convert the original white light that was composed of all visible wavelengths into a colored light composed of the less-absorbed wavelengths. In short, pigments work by subtraction. What is not absorbed is what you see.
Feathers, however, contain more than just pigments. They contain structures of many kinds, and some of them scatter or otherwise redirect the light that strikes them. White feathers contain structures that scatter all wavelengths in all directions. Many pigmented feathers, such as those of goldfinches, also contain structures that reflect light outward, thus enabling the pigments to make the feathers’ colors much more intense. The color itself is due to the pigment and its property of absorbing different wavelengths to different extents.
It is possible, however, for bird feathers—and many other biological structures—to be brightly colored without resorting to pigments at all. Such colors are collectively called structural colors, and these play roles in animal biology that complement and can to some extent differ from those of pigmentary colors. Here is a dramatic example of one type of structural coloration.
The black of Steller’s jays is due, as usual, to melanin. The brilliant blue, however, is a structural color. Internal structures within the feather, with dimensions in the range of wavelengths of light, scatter blue light preferentially. Some of that blue light ends up in the eyes the beholder and makes the jays look blue. The complete physics and structural details of the scattering process are currently the subject of intense investigation. For our purposes, it is sufficient to say that the blueness of the feathers of the Steller’s jay is due not to the presence of blue pigments but to the properties of submicroscopic internal structures made of proteins, which are themselves colorless.
Once again, however, in real life structural colors and pigment-based colors turn out to be functionally related. In individual Steller’s jays that fail to synthesize melanin, not only are the heads pale but the blue color is also considerably paler than usual. The likely explanation is that, while the wing and tail feathers are blue for structural reasons, they also contain melanin that absorbs light bouncing off the wing’s multitude of internal surfaces. This leaves primarily the blue light that has been scattered outward, and thereby makes the blue pure and intense. When the melanin is lacking, the scattered blue light is effectively diluted by the presence of other wavelengths that are no longer absorbed but are scattered and also make their way outward and to our eyes.
As in the yellow feathers of goldfinches, then, structural features and pigments interact in the blue feathers of jays. The difference is that in goldfinches the color comes from pigments, in jays the color comes from structures.
The intense blue of a Steller’s jay is an example of non-iridescent structural coloration. The brilliant colors of wild turkeys and a number of other bird species are examples of iridescent structural coloration. What’s the difference? The physics is complex and the boundary between the two no longer seems quite as sharp as it once did, but we can state the functional difference very simply:
- Non-iridescent structural colors look the same from all viewing angles.
- Iridescent structural colors change their color as the viewing angle changes and can even disappear altogether!
The importance of viewing angle in iridescent structural coloration is illustrated in the pair of photographs of a wild turkey below.
These two pictures were taken only a few seconds apart as the turkey was walking forward and also turning slightly. Compare the distribution of lights and darks, especially on the shoulders and the back. See where the bright red feathers on the side are located. The differences are the consequence of the importance of viewing angle, which can even make color disappear altogether. Now look at the wing feathers and the tail. Their colors have not changed at all, and neither has their brightness. Their color is due to pigments (melanins!), and the light scattering that is independent of viewing angle.
Our excursion through the world of color has taken us from the global to the molecular. We started by celebrating the arrival of spring. With spring come birds, staking out territories and seeking mates. Colored plumage, the more brilliant the better, is an important part of this annual activity. The colors are produced by pigments and by structural features of the feathers, sometimes alone but often in combination. Pigments are molecules. Structures are constructed out of molecules. We see light because of molecules in our eyes. Every human body, like the bodies of all living things, is made out of molecules. Indeed, the entire Cosmos of which we are a part is built out of atoms and molecules and tied together by light, by gravity, and by a handful of other forces.
In the 1980s, a wonderful women’s chorus named Libana sang a song with a striking line in it, “I am a child of the Universe.” As you enjoy the geese and the cardinals and the goldfinches, and seek the brilliant white of the heads of soaring eagles, pause and see if you too don’t feel like a child of the Universe!
So interesting, Johnny! Thank you once again for a fascinating blog post!
Fascinating as usual, Johnny. It would seem that the Anna’s hummers here (and perhaps the ruby-throats there) partake of that “structural” element in their wild, red coloring. And I recall learning that many butterflies do this as well. Am I right?
I certainly enjoyed your exploration of the colors of birds. Thank you!
One of the many things that was new to me was the role of reflection in producing the brilliant yellow of the goldfinch. I wanted to know more about that, did a little search and found this:
Hi John. I am due to give a 30 min talk on feathers at our winter Monday night nature gatherings. People from my local area meet at the pub and just talk about a subject they are interested in. We then discuss the topic over a beer. It is a fun relaxed, non academic way to delve into our natural world and learn a wee bit…We hope. So Thank you very much for simplifying some of the issues on light that I will be trying to get across as I know there will be ambushes laid out by ‘friends’.
All the best.
Hi, Mick. Sorry my response is a bit delayed. I hope your gathering went well! In case you or any of you or friends are interested, there are several earlier posts on light and color, notably Our Brightly Colored World (Nov. 29, 2015), Seeing Colors (Dec. 13, 2015), How Green Is My Forest (Dec. 27, 2015), Blue Skies and Red Sunsets (Mar. 20, 2016), and Flaming Forests (Dec. 11, 2016).